What are the theoretical and practical underpinnings of pluralism? How do constitutionalism and the rule of law mediate and potentially undermine plural value systems? Is pluralism viable in a time of rising autocracy? What are the relationships between authoritarianism and homogeneity of belief, thought, and political action? Is pluralism inconsistent with strong in-group solidarity and national identity? Is pluralism an inducement to moral relativism, political complacency, and superficial cosmopolitanism? As importantly, what specific practices, norms, and skills make pluralism functional? What practices are proven to support engagement with and mediation of differences? The purpose of this seminar is to explore these and other questions at the level of political and legal theory and also at the level of research into concrete practices of pluralism -- identifying conceptual relations and juxtapositions as well as practical obstacles to and evidence-based tools for bridgebuilding, dispute resolution, and effective communication in legal, political, and social communities constituted in difference. The seminar mixes traditional close reading and discussion of texts with presentation of cutting-edge research by nationally recognized experts. Students will develop and present a research paper on a topic of their choosing concerning the theory, practice, and/or law of pluralism. Project designs will be presented over the final two week of class. The course is open to graduate students by consent. After the term begins, students can transfer from section (LAW 01) into section (LAW 02), which meets the R requirement, with consent of the instructor. Students taking the seminar for R credit can take the seminar for either 2 or 3 units, depending on the paper length. Elements used in grading: Attendance, class participation, written assignments, final paper. The course is open to graduate students by consent. CONSENT APPLICATION: To apply for this course, students must complete a Consent Application Form available at SLS Registrar https://registrar.law.stanford.edu/. Cross-listed with Philosophy (PHIL 375L).
2-3 units · Law Honors/Pass/Restrd Cr/Fail
What are the theoretical and practical underpinnings of pluralism? How do constitutionalism and the rule of law mediate and potentially undermine plural value systems? Is pluralism viable in a time of rising autocracy? What are the relationships between authoritarianism and homogeneity of belief, thought, and political action? Is pluralism inconsistent with strong in-group solidarity and national identity? Is pluralism an inducement to moral relativism, political complacency, and superficial cosmopolitanism? As importantly, what specific practices, norms, and skills make pluralism functional? What practices are proven to support engagement with and mediation of differences? The purpose of this seminar is to explore these and other questions at the level of political and legal theory and also at the level of research into concrete practices of pluralism -- identifying conceptual relations and juxtapositions as well as practical obstacles to and evidence-based tools for bridgebuilding, dispute resolution, and effective communication in legal, political, and social communities constituted in difference. The seminar mixes traditional close reading and discussion of texts with presentation of cutting-edge research by nationally recognized experts. Students will develop and present a research paper on a topic of their choosing concerning the theory, practice, and/or law of pluralism. Project designs will be presented over the final two week of class. The course is open to graduate students by consent. After the term begins, students can transfer from section (01) into section (02), which meets the R requirement, with consent of the instructor. Students taking the seminar for R credit can take the seminar for either 2 or 3 units, depending on the paper length. Elements used in grading: Attendance, class participation, written assignments, final paper. The course is open to graduate students by consent. CONSENT APPLICATION: To apply for this course, students must complete a Consent Application Form available at SLS Registrar https://registrar.law.stanford.edu/. Cross-listed with Philosophy (PHIL 375L).
Offered in Winter 2026 at Stanford University.